Coaching centre deaths: Court grants bail to SUV driver after cops drop culpable homicide charge

A court here on Thursday allowed the second bail plea of an SUV driver, arrested for his alleged role in drowning of three civil services aspirants in the basement of a coaching centre.Three civil service aspirants lost their lives in a flooding incident at a coaching center in east Delhi. While their classmates managed to escape, Shreya Yadav (25), Tanya Soni, and Navin Delvin (28) were tragically trapped in the flooded basement library. Their bodies were discovered hours later1.

Additionally, in central Delhi’s Old Rajinder Nagar area, three other students—Shreya Yadav from Uttar Pradesh, Tania Soni from Telangana, and Nevin Dalwin from Kerala—died after the basement of a coaching center was flooded due to heavy rain2.

The incident has sparked ongoing protests against alleged negligence by authorities in ensuring student safety during monsoons. Demonstrations continue, demanding justice for the victims3.

During the proceedings, the Delhi Police told the court that they had decided to drop harsher charge of culpable homicide not amounting to murder against Manuj Kathuria, the SUV driver.

Additional Sessions Judge Rakesh Kumar was hearing an appeal against the denial of bail to Kathuria by a magisterial court on Wednesday."The bail is allowed," the judge said.

Kathuria was accused of driving his Force Gurkha car through the street that was flooded by rainwater, causing the water to swell and breach the gates of the three-storey building housing the coaching centre and inundate the basement.

During the proceedings, the Delhi police told the court that they had decided to drop 'culpable homicide not amounting to murder' charge against Kathuria.

"During the further investigation, as carried out in the preceding 48 hours, it has transpired that the ingredients of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) section 105 (culpable homicide not amounting to murder) is, at this stage, not being sufficiently established," the investigating officer (IO) said in his reply to the appeal.

"The same can be better assessed when the expert team from IIT-Delhi visits the spot and post inspection, submits its findings. Thus, as of now, the primary offence against the accused is of Section 281 BNS (rash driving or riding on public way) for which the court may kindly pass appropriate orders as deemed fit," the IO added.

On Wednesday, terming the offence as "serious", the magisterial court had denied bail to Kathuria, saying the plea was "untenable at this stage".

The denial of bail by the magisterial court came hours after a Delhi High Court bench headed by Acting Chief Justice Manmohan castigated the police for its "strange" probe by arresting the driver.

"What is Delhi Police doing? Have they lost it? What are its officials who are monitoring the probe doing? This is a cover up or what?" the high court said in the forenoon while hearing a PIL seeking a probe into the incident.

Kathuria was arrested on Monday along with four co-owners of the basement.Police have arrested seven people after three students drowned in the basement of an exam coaching centre in the Indian capital Delhi.

The students, who were enrolled in a tuition centre called Rau's IAS Study Circle for the country’s notoriously challenging civil service entrance exams, died when a burst pipeline flooded the building's basement amid heavy rains on Saturday.

Tanya Soni from Telangana state, Shreya Yadav from Uttar Pradesh and Nevin Delvin from Kerala were all in their twenties. Several fellow students trapped in the basement were saved after a seven-hour rescue operation.

The incident sparked a public outcry in India, where hundreds of thousands of young men and women enrol in such coaching institutions every year to prepare for exams that, if they are successful, could secure them prized jobs with federal and state governments.

Among those arrested on Monday was the coaching centre’s owner, police said. He has been charged with culpable homicide.

Three dozen students and staff were in the basement when water began entering the building in Old Rajinder Nagar at around 7pm local time on Saturday following heavy rain.

The entrance gate of the building collapsed, students told local reporters. Residents alleged that the drainage system in the area was clogged with silt.

Authorities later found the coaching centre was illegally using the basement as a library.

A student said the doors to the library were fitted with biometric locks just days prior to the incident.

"It seems that due to waterlogging, the biometric system failed and people could not get out," Rajan, who only gave his first name, told BBC Hindi.

The incident triggered protests against the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and the coaching centre, leading authorities to deploy police to maintain order.

"We will continue our protest against coaching centres which are not following rules and putting the lives of many students like us in danger," Ayush, a student identified only by his first name, told PTI news agency. "We are planning to hold a candlelight march and start a hunger strike until all our demands are met.”

Authorities in Delhi said they have sealed several coaching centres found to be "operating in basements in violation of rules".

A similar crackdown has been ordered by four other states, including Rajasthan, where thousands of young students move to study for the notoriously competitive entrance exams.

The federal home ministry has formed a committee to investigate the deaths, "fix responsibility, suggest measures and recommend policy changes".

VK Saxena, Delhi’s administrator, announced compensation of Rs1,000,000 (£9,289 ) for the families of each of the dead students. He also promised action within 24 hours against officials found responsible for the tragedy.

Previous Post Next Post